Comparison

BMW i4 vs Tesla Model 3

BMW i4 vs Tesla Model 3 from EPA and Transport Canada records: range and efficiency by version and wheel size, horsepower, size and weight.

The BMW i4 and the Tesla Model 3 are the two electric four-doors most often weighed against each other in the US, and the federal records make the comparison unusually clean: both are rated by EPA for range and efficiency, both have rated output in the EPA Test Car List, and both are measured by Transport Canada. This page uses those sources and nothing else.

All figures are for the 2025 model year. EPA rates several i4 versions separately by wheel size, and the wheel turns out to matter as much as the badge.

Size and weight

MeasurementBMW i4Tesla Model 3
Length188.2 in185.8 in
Width72.8 in72.8 in
Height57.1 in56.7 in
Wheelbase112.6 in113.4 in
Curb weight4,685 lb (i4) / 5,049 lb (i4 M50)3,805 lb (RWD) / 4,030 lb (Long Range AWD)
Front/rear weight split48/5248/52

Source: Transport Canada vehicle specifications via NHTSA vPIC, 2025 model year. Transport Canada classifies both as four-door sedans; BMW markets the i4 as a Gran Coupe.

Width and weight distribution are identical in the record, and the i4 is 2.4 in longer on a wheelbase 0.8 in shorter. The difference is mass. The base i4 entry is 880 lb heavier than the rear-drive Model 3, and the i4 M50 is 1,019 lb heavier than the Model 3 Long Range AWD. That gap shows up again in the efficiency figures.

Range, efficiency and output

Version (2025)DriveRated hpEPA rangeEPA combined
i4 eDrive35, 18-in wheelsRWD282266 mi116 MPGe
i4 eDrive40, 18-in wheelsRWD335318 mi112 MPGe
i4 eDrive40, 19-in wheelsRWD335295 mi104 MPGe
i4 xDrive40, 18-in wheelsAWD396287 mi101 MPGe
i4 M50, 19-in wheelsAWD536267 mi94 MPGe
i4 M50, 20-in wheelsAWD536227 mi80 MPGe
Model 3 Long Range RWDRWD302363 mi137 MPGe
Model 3 Long Range RWD, 19-in wheelsRWD286346 mi131 MPGe
Model 3 Long Range AWDAWD397*346 mi128 MPGe
Model 3 Performance AWDAWD510298 mi109 MPGe

Sources: range and MPGe from the EPA fueleconomy.gov dataset; rated horsepower from the EPA Test Car List, 2025 model year. *Listed in the Test Car List as “Long Range AWD-E”.

On every federal efficiency measure the Model 3 versions rank ahead. The most efficient i4, the eDrive35 on 18-inch wheels, is rated 116 MPGe; the least efficient Model 3 in the 2025 listing, the Performance AWD, is rated 109. In energy terms EPA puts the i4 eDrive40 on 18-inch wheels at 30.2 kWh per 100 miles and the Model 3 Long Range RWD at 24.6. On range, the longest-range i4 is rated 318 miles, the longest-range Model 3 363.

Output overlaps. At the top, the i4 M50’s 536 hp is above the Model 3 Performance’s 510 in the Test Car List. In the middle, the i4 xDrive40 (396 hp) and the Model 3 Long Range AWD (397 hp) are effectively level.

Wheel size moves the i4 more than anything else

EPA’s separate listings by wheel size show how much the wheel option matters. The same i4 M50 loses 40 miles of rated range going from 19-inch to 20-inch wheels, 267 to 227. The eDrive40 loses 23 miles going from 18 to 19 inches. Anyone comparing range numbers should check which wheel the figure belongs to; the full record for each version is on the 2025 i4 eDrive40 card and the 2025 i4 M50 card.

BMW’s naming follows the drivetrain: eDrive versions have one motor driving the rear wheels, xDrive versions add a front motor for all-wheel drive, the same badge logic covered in our guide to xDrive. The i4 shares its body with the 4 Series Gran Coupe. The rest of BMW’s battery-electric range is in our overview of BMW electric cars.

What the numbers do not settle

The federal records do not give acceleration, charging speed, cargo volume to a common method or price, and we do not quote those. Rated range is a standardized test result, not a promise for a given trip.

Common questions

Does the BMW i4 or the Tesla Model 3 have more range?

The Model 3. For 2025 EPA rates the Model 3 Long Range RWD at 363 miles and the longest-range i4, the eDrive40 on 18-inch wheels, at 318 miles.

Which is more efficient?

The Model 3, in every version EPA lists. Ratings run 109 to 137 MPGe combined for the 2025 Model 3 and 80 to 116 MPGe for the 2025 i4.

Is the i4 bigger than the Model 3?

It is 2.4 in longer and 0.4 in taller, with the same width, in Transport Canada’s records. It is also heavier: 4,685 lb for the base i4 entry against 3,805 lb for the rear-drive Model 3.

Why do some i4 versions have two range ratings?

EPA rates each wheel size separately. On the 2025 i4 M50, the 20-inch wheel lowers rated range from 267 to 227 miles.