Comparison

BMW vs Mercedes: Reliability

BMW vs Mercedes reliability from NHTSA owner complaints 2007–2022: which components each brand's complaints concern, the Takata effect and why counts mislead.

“Which is more reliable, BMW or Mercedes?” is one of the most-asked questions about either brand, and almost every answer to it rests on surveys or rankings whose method you cannot see. This page uses a record anyone can check: the owner complaints filed with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) for model years 2007 through 2022. We downloaded them for both brands and read them the same way.

That record cannot tell you which brand breaks more often. It can tell you, with real precision, what owners of each brand complain about — and the two answers are strikingly different.

Why we do not compare totals

A complaint count is not a failure rate. Turning one into a rate needs the number of cars on the road, and neither manufacturer publishes model-by-model sales in a form that supports it. A brand that sold more cars will collect more complaints with no difference in quality. Complaints are also self-selected: people file when something has gone badly wrong, not slightly wrong.

There is a practical reason too. NHTSA indexes complaints under whatever model name the owner or manufacturer used, and Mercedes-Benz records appear under the make spelled both “MERCEDES-BENZ” and “MERCEDES BENZ”. We gathered every complaint we could reach for both brands and kept each one once, under the vehicle it names: 15,070 for BMW and 14,157 for Mercedes-Benz. Those totals depend on how completely each brand’s names could be searched, so we compare only shares — what proportion of each brand’s own complaints concern each part of the car. (Our common BMW problems page counts 15,341 BMW records because it assigns them by the search that found them; the shares differ by tenths of a point.)

First, take out the airbags

Airbag complaintsBMWMercedes-Benz
Share of all complaints16.8%26.5%
Airbag complaints naming Takata9082,271
Airbag share, model years 2007–201519.6%33.6%
Airbag share, model years 2016–20227.2%6.3%

Both brands fitted Takata airbag inflators that were later recalled, and complaints about that recall swamp the older model years. For Mercedes-Benz a third of all 2007–2015 complaints are airbag complaints. After 2015 the two brands sit within a point of each other. Anyone ranking these brands on raw complaint totals for those years is largely ranking them by Takata exposure. Everything below therefore excludes airbag complaints: 12,536 for BMW and 10,409 for Mercedes-Benz.

What the rest are about

NHTSA category, share of non-airbag complaintsBMWMercedes-Benz
Engine (either engine category)39.4%19.2%
Electrical system24.1%18.7%
Power train13.1%8.3%
Fuel/propulsion system9.9%13.4%
Steering5.4%10.0%
Structure4.7%8.3%
Suspension1.7%7.4%
Service brakes5.2%7.3%

One complaint can carry several categories, so the columns add to more than 100%. The pattern is clear anyway. BMW owners’ complaints concentrate on the engine and the electrics. Mercedes-Benz owners’ complaints are spread wider, with steering, structure and suspension each taking a far larger share than at BMW.

The parts owners name

Searching the complaint text for specific parts, with the same search on both brands, sharpens the picture:

Named in the complaint, share of non-airbag complaintsBMWMercedes-Benz
Water pump3.4%0.1%
High-pressure fuel pump3.4%0.4%
Timing chain2.5%0.6%
Stalling8.2%4.1%
Rust or corrosion0.8%7.4%
Fuel smell0.6%7.7%
Steering lock0.4%3.0%
Sunroof or moonroof2.7%5.4%

The BMW column is a story of engine ancillaries — pumps, chains and the stalling they cause, which is examined model by model in BMW years to avoid. The Mercedes-Benz column is a story of body and fuel-system complaints: 346 of its 795 suspension complaints mention rust or corrosion, and owners describe a smell of fuel in 7.7% of non-airbag records, against 0.6% for BMW.

Car against car

PairBMW signatureMercedes-Benz signature
3 Series / C-ClassHigh-pressure fuel pump 5.4%, stalling 10.1%Rust 13.0%, steering lock 8.1%
5 Series / E-ClassHigh-pressure fuel pump 4.7%, timing chain 3.8%Fuel smell 19.6%, rust 11.0%
X3 / GLK and GLCTiming chain 6.4%, coolant 5.5%Fuel smell 8.7%, sunroof 6.3%
X5 / M-Class and GLEWater pump 6.9%, stalling 7.0%Stalling 7.7%, sunroof 3.5%

Shares are of each car’s own non-airbag complaints, model years 2007–2022. Two entries stand out. On the C-Class, 242 of 615 steering complaints describe the steering lock. On the E-Class, 253 of 450 fuel/propulsion complaints describe a fuel smell. Neither has a counterpart of that size on the BMW side.

Why there are no recall counts here

We count recall campaigns per model year for BMW, and those figures are on BMW years to avoid. We could not do the same for Mercedes-Benz reliably. NHTSA’s recall index files Mercedes-Benz models under individual names and both spellings of the make: a query for a 2015 C300 returns 11 campaigns under “MERCEDES-BENZ” and none under “MERCEDES BENZ”, while a 2008 C300 returns none under the first spelling and seven under the second. A complete count would depend on guessing every name and spelling under which a campaign might be filed, and we could not confirm that we had them all. A count that might be incomplete would make Mercedes-Benz look better than it is, so we leave it out.

For the broader comparison of the two lineups, see BMW vs Mercedes; for Audi’s complaint record, see BMW vs Audi reliability.

Common questions

Is BMW or Mercedes more reliable?

The federal complaint record cannot answer that, because there are no sales figures to divide by. What it shows is that the two brands fail differently: BMW complaints concentrate on the engine and electrics, Mercedes-Benz complaints on steering, structure, suspension and the fuel system.

Why do older Mercedes-Benz models have so many airbag complaints?

The Takata inflator recall. Airbags are 33.6% of Mercedes-Benz complaints for model years 2007–2015, and 2,271 of its airbag complaints name Takata. For 2016–2022 the share is 6.3%, slightly below BMW’s 7.2%.

What do Mercedes-Benz owners complain about most, apart from airbags?

The electrical system (18.7% of non-airbag complaints) and the engine (19.2%), followed by the fuel/propulsion system. By named part, fuel smell (7.7%) and rust or corrosion (7.4%) lead.

What do BMW owners complain about most?

The engine, in 39.4% of non-airbag complaints, and the electrical system, in 24.1%. The most often named parts are the water pump and the high-pressure fuel pump, each in 3.4%.