Comparison

BMW vs Mercedes-Benz

BMW vs Mercedes-Benz in EPA records: how many versions each sells, rear vs all-wheel drive, cylinders, mild hybrids, EV range and mpg by class.

BMW and Mercedes-Benz have sold against each other in the United States for longer than most of their buyers have been driving, and most comparisons of the two come down to taste. This one does not. It compares the two lineups as the federal government records them: every version each brand certified with the Environmental Protection Agency for fuel economy, from the EPA’s public data file. That tells you how the ranges are built — how many versions, which wheels are driven, which engines, how much is electric — and nothing about which car you will enjoy more.

One unit runs through every number below. A version is one EPA-certified configuration: a 330i and a 330i xDrive are two versions, as are a C300 and a C300 4MATIC. Counts show the breadth of a lineup, not how many cars were sold. We have no sales figures, and no prices.

Two lineups at a glance

Model year 2025, EPA dataBMWMercedes-Benz
Certified versions11488
Model lines (EPA base model)2016
SUVs among the versions31 (27%)32 (36%)
All-wheel or four-wheel drive79 (69%)74 (84%)
Rear-wheel drive35 (31%)10 (11%)
Manual transmission40
Fully electric3320
Plug-in hybrid711
Mild hybrid (EPA “Hybrid”)3549

We use 2025 because it is the most recent model year in our extract that both brands have certified in full. The 2026 file is still filling.

How the ranges grew

Model yearBMW versionsMercedes-Benz versions
20055952
20108343
201512177
202011591
202511488

BMW has certified more versions than Mercedes-Benz in every one of these years. Much of the difference is bodywork rather than model lines: BMW sells the same car as a coupe, a convertible and a Gran Coupe more often, and in 2025 its 4 Series alone accounts for 12 versions and its 8 Series for 10. The model index shows how each BMW line breaks down.

Rear-wheel drive: both moved away, at different speeds

In 2005 the two brands looked almost identical on this measure: 76% of BMW versions and 75% of Mercedes-Benz versions drove the rear wheels only. Twenty years later both had shifted toward all-wheel drive, but not equally. BMW still certifies 35 rear-drive versions, 31% of its range; Mercedes-Benz certifies 10, or 11%, and four of those are electric.

The manual transmission tells the same story more sharply. BMW’s 2025 range keeps four manual versions — the M2, M3, M4 and Z4 M40i, all with six speeds. Mercedes-Benz certified its last manual in our data for 2015, an SLK250. How BMW’s all-wheel-drive system works is covered in xDrive explained.

Engines: where the V12 survived

Among the 2025 versions with a combustion engine, the cylinder mix is close: BMW has 30 four-cylinder, 33 six-cylinder and 18 eight-cylinder versions; Mercedes-Benz has 31, 17 and 19, plus one twelve-cylinder. That last line is the visible difference. BMW’s last V12 version in the EPA data is the 2022 model year; Mercedes-Benz still certifies one in the 2027 file.

Both brands have made the 48-volt-class mild hybrid their standard gasoline engine, and the EPA labels them simply “Hybrid”. BMW’s 35 run on 44- or 46-volt lithium-ion packs; Mercedes-Benz’s 49 on 48-volt packs. These are not self-charging hybrids that drive on electricity — that is a different design, covered on our BMW vs Lexus page.

Electrification

BMW’s first fully electric car in the EPA data is the 2011 ActiveE, followed by the 2014 i3. Mercedes-Benz’s first is the 2014 B-Class Electric Drive. In 2025 BMW certified 33 electric versions and Mercedes-Benz 20.

Electric versions, 2025BMWMercedes-Benz
Median EPA range278 miles284.5 miles
Longest EPA range318 miles (i4 eDrive40)390 miles (EQS 450+)
Median combined efficiency87 MPGe83.5 MPGe

The plug-in hybrids point in different directions. Mercedes-Benz’s 11 are mostly high-performance: eight are AMG E Performance or AMG hybrid versions, leaving the GLC350e, GLE450e and S580e. BMW’s seven include the X5 xDrive50e, the 550e and 750e, the XM and the M5. Our list of BMW electric cars follows every model year.

Fuel economy by size class

Combined EPA mpg, median of the gasoline and mild-hybrid versions in each EPA size class, 2025. Medians count every version equally, so a class with many coupe variants weighs those heavily.

EPA classBMWMercedes-Benz
Compact and smaller cars26 mpg23 mpg
Midsize cars24 mpg27 mpg
Small SUVs26 mpg26 mpg
Standard SUVs19 mpg17 mpg

Neither brand leads across the board, and the differences within a class are smaller than the differences between a base version and a performance version of the same car. For individual versions, each specification card carries its own EPA figures.

Reliability is a separate question with a separate method, on BMW vs Mercedes reliability. Audi joins the comparison on BMW vs Audi vs Mercedes.

Common questions

Does BMW or Mercedes-Benz have more models?

By EPA certification, BMW. For model year 2025 BMW certified 114 versions across 20 model lines, Mercedes-Benz 88 across 16. BMW’s lead comes largely from offering the same car in more body styles.

Which brand still sells rear-wheel-drive cars?

Both, but BMW far more of them. In 2025, 35 of BMW’s 114 versions were rear-wheel drive, against 10 of 88 at Mercedes-Benz. In 2005 the shares were nearly equal, at 76% and 75%.

Which has more electric cars, BMW or Mercedes?

BMW certified 33 electric versions for 2025 and Mercedes-Benz 20. The Mercedes EQS 450+ has the longest EPA range of either brand at 390 miles; BMW’s longest is the i4 eDrive40 at 318.

Are BMW and Mercedes mild hybrids the same as a Lexus hybrid?

No. Both German brands use 44- to 48-volt systems that assist the gasoline engine. The EPA files them under the same “Hybrid” label as Lexus’s full hybrids, whose 2025 battery packs run from 222 to 311 volts.