Comparison

BMW vs Audi vs Mercedes

BMW, Audi and Mercedes-Benz side by side from EPA and NHTSA data: lineup size, drivetrains, engines, electrification and owner complaint patterns.

BMW, Audi and Mercedes-Benz are the three German luxury brands most American shoppers weigh against each other. This page puts all three side by side on two public federal records — the Environmental Protection Agency’s fuel economy certifications and the owner complaints filed with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration — and links out to the two-brand pages where each pairing is examined in depth. It does not rank the brands, and it does not publish prices: we have no source for them.

The EPA counts below are versions: one certified configuration each, so a 330i and a 330i xDrive count as two. That measures how broad each range is, not how many cars each brand sold.

The three lineups in one table

Model year 2025, EPA dataBMWAudiMercedes-Benz
Certified versions1146488
SUV share of versions27%59%36%
All-wheel or four-wheel drive69%94%84%
Rear-wheel-drive versions35410
Manual-transmission versions400
Combustion versions: 4 / 6 / 8 cylinders30 / 33 / 1818 / 16 / 631 / 17 / 19
Mild-hybrid versions352149
Plug-in hybrid versions7111
Electric versions332320
Median electric range278 mi278 mi284.5 mi
First electric model year in EPA data201120192014

Audi also certifies one five-cylinder version and Mercedes-Benz one twelve-cylinder; BMW’s last V12 in the EPA file is the 2022 model year. Model year 2025 is the latest our extract holds complete for all three.

What the table says, brand by brand

BMW has the widest range by versions and the most rear-wheel-drive and manual versions left. Much of its count is bodywork: the same car as coupe, convertible and Gran Coupe. It also has the largest electric range of the three. In depth: BMW vs Mercedes and BMW vs Audi.

Audi has been an all-wheel-drive brand throughout: 78% of its versions in 2005, 94% in 2025, against 24% and 69% for BMW. It is also the most SUV-heavy of the three, with 59% of its 2025 versions. The drivetrain history is on BMW vs Audi.

Mercedes-Benz has moved furthest from rear-wheel drive — 75% of its versions in 2005, 11% in 2025 — and leans hardest on 48-volt mild hybrids, with 49. It is the only one of the three still certifying a V12, and its EQS 450+ carries the longest electric range of any of the three brands’ 2025 versions, 390 miles.

What owners complain about

NHTSA’s owner complaints for model years 2007–2022 cannot rank the brands: nobody publishes the sales figures needed to turn a complaint count into a failure rate. What they do show is how each brand’s complaints divide up. Each complaint is counted once, under the vehicle it names, and airbag complaints — dominated in the older years by the Takata inflator recall that hit all three — are set aside first.

NHTSA complaints, model years 2007–2022BMWAudiMercedes-Benz
Airbag share of all complaints16.8%19.7%26.5%
Airbag share, model years 2016–20227.2%8.7%6.3%
Engine, share of non-airbag complaints39.4%28.9%19.2%
Electrical system24.1%23.4%18.7%
Steering5.4%8.9%10.0%
Most distinctive named problemHigh-pressure fuel pump, 3.4%Oil consumption, 4.0%Fuel smell, 7.7%; rust, 7.4%

The three records read like three different kinds of trouble: BMW’s centered on the engine and its ancillaries, Audi’s on oil consumption, cooling and turbochargers, and Mercedes-Benz’s on the body, steering and fuel system. The method, the part-by-part tables and the car-against-car pairs are on BMW vs Mercedes reliability and BMW vs Audi reliability. For BMW alone, model by model, see common BMW problems and BMW years to avoid.

Where to go next

Every BMW line we document is listed in the model index, and the all-wheel-drive system that now covers most of the range is explained in BMW xDrive explained. If Lexus is also on your list, its very different approach to hybrids is set out on BMW vs Lexus.

Common questions

Which brand has the most models: BMW, Audi or Mercedes?

BMW. For model year 2025 it certified 114 versions with the EPA, against 88 for Mercedes-Benz and 64 for Audi.

Which German brand is most likely to be all-wheel drive?

Audi: 94% of its 2025 versions are all-wheel drive, against 84% for Mercedes-Benz and 69% for BMW.

Which is most reliable: BMW, Audi or Mercedes?

Federal complaint data cannot rank them, because there is no sales denominator. It shows that the brands’ complaints concern different things: the engine at BMW, oil consumption and cooling at Audi, the body, steering and fuel system at Mercedes-Benz.

Which of the three has the most electric cars?

BMW, with 33 electric versions for model year 2025, against 23 for Audi and 20 for Mercedes-Benz. The longest single EPA range belongs to the Mercedes EQS 450+, at 390 miles.